10 Cheap Halloween Candy Alternatives Kids Will Love

Looking for something fun to hand out besides candy this Halloween? Whether you’re trying to avoid all that sugar, need allergy-friendly options, or just want to give trick-or-treaters something a little different, there are plenty of cheap Halloween candy alternatives kids will actually love!

And you don’t have to spend a fortune! Dollar Tree is one of my favorite places to look for inexpensive Halloween goodies. I was just there checking out the Halloween treats, and it’s amazing how many fun little things you can find without spending a ton.

You can also grab Halloween party favors in bulk on Amazon, which is especially handy if you’re expecting a lot of trick-or-treaters or putting together classroom goodie bags.

Here are 10 fun Halloween candy alternatives worth checking out this year!

1. Dollar Tree Halloween Treats & Party Favors

Before spending a bunch of money online, check your local Dollar Tree! It’s a great place to hunt for inexpensive Halloween goodies, from stickers and pencils to small toys, party favors, and spooky surprises.

Look for multipacks you can divide between trick-or-treaters to stretch your Halloween budget even further. Selection varies by store, so grab the good stuff when you see it!

Check out my recent Dollar Tree Halloween finds in the video below!

2. Halloween Paddle Balls

These old-school toys are still a hit! Halloween paddle balls are inexpensive, fun, and something kids can play with long after their Halloween candy disappears. Look for multipacks to get the best price.

3. Halloween Novelty Toy Assortments

Can’t decide what to hand out? Grab a big assortment of Halloween toys! These packs can include things like mini puzzles, bracelets, plastic rings, and other spooky surprises. They’re especially handy when you’re expecting a crowd.

4. Creepy Fake Bugs

Want to get a few screams out of your trick-or-treaters? Hand out fake cockroaches, spiders, or other creepy plastic bugs! They’re inexpensive, perfectly spooky, and sure to get a reaction.

5. Halloween Stamps

Little ghosts, pumpkins, bats, and witches make adorable Halloween stamps! Kids can use them for crafts, cards, and decorating paper. Look for individually packaged or self-inking stamps that are easy to hand out.

6. Chattering Vampire Teeth

These silly little toys are perfect for Halloween! Wind-up chattering teeth and vampire fangs are a fun change from traditional candy. They’re especially entertaining for older kids who love anything a little ridiculous.

7. Skeleton Pens & Halloween Pencils

Here’s something kids can actually use! Skeleton-shaped pens, Halloween pencils, and spooky erasers are inexpensive alternatives that work especially well for classroom Halloween parties.

Dollar stores are also worth checking for seasonal pencil multipacks.

8. Halloween Finger Puppets

Mini witches, ghosts, monsters, and pumpkins make cute little finger puppets. These are a fun choice for younger trick-or-treaters and can also be used for Halloween party games or classroom activities.

9. Mini Halloween Bubbles

Bubbles are always a favorite with little kids! Mini Halloween bubble bottles are easy to hand out, inexpensive when purchased in bulk, and perfect for party favor bags.

10. Bouncy Eyeballs

These are just creepy enough to be perfect for Halloween! Bouncy eyeballs are fun, inexpensive, and easy to buy in larger quantities. Some even glow in the dark!

Where to Find Cheap Halloween Candy Alternatives

You don’t have to spend a fortune to hand out something fun this Halloween! Here are a few places worth checking:

• Dollar Tree: Great for seasonal party favors, stickers, pencils, and inexpensive multipacks.
• Amazon: Best for comparing larger bulk assortments when you have lots of trick-or-treaters.
• Walmart: Check the seasonal Halloween section for party favors and classroom goodies.
• Target: Look for Halloween favors in the seasonal aisles and value sections.

Don’t Forget the Teal Pumpkin Project!

Handing out non-food treats is also a great way to include kids with food allergies and other dietary restrictions. The Teal Pumpkin Project encourages families to offer non-food treats so more children can safely participate in Halloween fun.

If you’re participating, put a teal pumpkin outside your home to let families know you have non-food treats available. Keep them separate from candy to help avoid cross-contact.

Safety tip: Choose age-appropriate treats and avoid tiny toys, small balls, and other choking hazards for children under 3.

More Free & Cheap Halloween Fun

• FREE Printable Halloween Pumpkin Stencils
• Halloween Party Games Using Household Items
• Fun Halloween Ghost Treats
• More Halloween Deals, Freebies & Money-Saving Ideas

Looking for more freebies? We’ve got tons of FREE magazines, kids freebies, samples, activities and more you can grab! Check back often—we’re always adding new ones.